@prologic@twtxt.net Do you have a link to some past discussion?
Would the GDPR would apply to a one-person client like jenny? I seriously hope not. If someone asks me to delete an email they sent me, I donāt think I have to honour that request, no matter how European they are.
I am really bothered by the idea that someone could force me to delete my private, personal record of my interactions with them. Would I have to delete my journal entries about them too if they asked?
Maybe a public-facing client like yarnd needs to consider this, but that also bothers me. I was actually thinking about making an Internet Archive style twtxt archiver, letting you explore past twts, including long-dead feeds, see edit histories, deleted twts, etc.
Halfbrick+ Lets You Play Popular iOS Games Like Fruit Ninja, Jetpack Joyride and Mega Jump for $2.99/Month
Halfbrick Studios is a game company best known for super popular iOS titles like Fruit Ninja and Jetpack Joyride, which have historically been freemium titles. Starting last year, Halfbrick decided to go with a different monetization model, offering all of its games for a low monthly fee.
[Halfb ⦠ā Read more
I wrote some code to try out non-hash reply subjects formatted as (replyto ), while keeping the ability to use the existing hash style.
I donāt think we need to decide all at once. If clients add support for a new method then people can use it if they like. The downside of course is that this costs developer time, so I decided to invest a few hours of my own time into a proof of concept.
With apologies to @movq@www.uninformativ.de for corrupting jennyās beautiful code. I donāt write this expecting you to incorporate the patch, because it does complicate things and might not be a direction you want to go in. But if you like any part of this approach feel free to use bits of it; I release the patch under jennyās current LICENCE.
Supporting both kinds of reply in jenny was complicated because each email can only have one Message-Id, and because itās possible the target twt will not be seen until after the twt referencing it. The following patch uses an sqlite database to keep track of known (url, timestamp) pairs, as well as a separate table of (url, timestamp) pairs that havenāt been seen yet but are wanted. When one of those āwantedā twts is finally seen, the mail file gets rewritten to include the appropriate In-Reply-To header.
Patch based on jenny commit 73a5ea81.
https://www.falsifian.org/a/oDtr/patch0.txt
Not implemented:
- Composing twts using the (replyto ā¦) format.
- Probably other important things Iām forgetting.
Can I get someone like maybe @xuu@txt.sour.is or @abucci@anthony.buc.ci or even @eldersnake@we.loveprivacy.club ā If you have some spare time ā to test this yarnd PR that upgrades the Bitcask dependency for its internal database to v2? š
VERY IMPORTANT If you do; Please Please Please backup your yarn.db database first! š
Heaven knows I donāt want to be responsible for fucking up a production database here or there š¤£
Location Addressing is fine in smaller or single systems. But when youāre talking about large decentralised systems with no single point of control (kind of the point) things like independable variable integrity become quite important.
@movq@www.uninformativ.de could it be possible to have compressed_subject(msg_singlelined) be configurable, so only a certain number of characters get displayed, ending on ellipses? Right now the entire twtxt is crammed into the Subject:. This request aims to make twtxts display on mutt/neomutt, etc. more like emails do.
Oh. looks like its 4 chars. git show 64bf
Oh. looks like its 4 chars. git show 64bf
i feel like we should isolate a subset of markdown that makes sense and built it into lextwt. it already has support for links and images. maybe basic formatting bold, italic. possibly block quote and bullet lists. no tables or footnotes
i feel like we should isolate a subset of markdown that makes sense and built it into lextwt. it already has support for links and images. maybe basic formatting bold, italic. possibly block quote and bullet lists. no tables or footnotes
@prologic@twtxt.net Wikipedia claims sha1 is vulnerable to a āchosen-prefix attackā, which I gather means I can write any two twts I like, and then cause them to have the exact same sha1 hash by appending something. I guess a twt ending in random junk might look suspcious, but perhaps the junk could be worked into an image URL like
. If thatās not possible now maybe it will be later.git only uses sha1 because theyāre stuck with it: migrating is very hard. There was an effort to move git to sha256 but I donāt know its status. I think there is progress being made with Game Of Trees, a git clone that uses the same on-disk format.
I canāt imagine any benefit to using sha1, except that maybe some very old software might support sha1 but not sha256.
@movq@www.uninformativ.de Agreed that hashes have a benefit. I came up with a similar example where when I twted about an 11-character hash collision. Perhaps hashes could be made optional somehow. Like, you could use the āreplytoā idea and then additionally put a hash somewhere if you want to lock in which version of the twt you are replying to.
Iām not advocating in either direction, btw. I havenāt made up my mind yet. š Just braindumping here.
The (replyto:ā¦) proposal is definitely more in the spirit of twtxt, Iād say. Itās much simpler, anyone can use it even with the simplest tools, no need for any client code. That is certainly a great property, if you ask me, and itās things like that that brought me to twtxt in the first place.
Iād also say that in our tiny little community, message integrity simply doesnāt matter. Signed feeds donāt matter. I signed my feed for a while using GPG, someone else did the same, but in the end, nobody cares. The community is so tiny, thereās enough āimplicit trustā or whatever you want to call it.
If twtxt/Yarn was to grow bigger, then this would become a concern again. But even Mastodon allows editing, so how much of a problem can it really be? š
I do have to āadmitā, though, that hashes feel better. It feels good to know that we can clearly identify a certain twt. It feels more correct and stable.
Hm.
I suspect that the (replyto:ā¦) proposal would work just as well in practice.
@movq@www.uninformativ.de ooooh, nice! commit 62a2b7735749f2ff3c9306dd984ad28f853595c5:
Crawl archived feeds in āfetch-context
Like, very much! :-)
@quark@ferengi.one I donāt really mind if the twt gets edited before I even fetch it. I think itās the idea of my computer discarding old versions itās fetched, especially if itās shown them to me, that bugs me.
But I do like @movq@www.uninformativ.deās suggestion on this thread that feeds could contain both the original and the edited twt. I guess it would be up to the author.
@quark@ferengi.one None. I like being able to see edit history for the same reason.
@prologic@twtxt.net I wouldnāt want my client to honour delete requests. I like my computerās memory to be better than mine, not worse, so it would bug me if I remember seeing something and my computer canāt find it.
Thereās a simple reason all the current hashes end in a or q: the hash is 256 bits, the base32 encoding chops that into groups of 5 bits, and 256 isnāt divisible by 5. The last character of the base32 encoding just has that left-over single bit (256 mod 5 = 1).
So I agree with #3 below, but do you have a source for #1, #2 or #4? I would expect any lack of variability in any part of a hash functionās output would make it more vulnerable to attacks, so designers of hash functions would want to make the whole output vary as much as possible.
Other than the divisible-by-5 thing, my current intuition is it doesnāt matter what part you take.
Hash Structure: Hashes are typically designed so that their outputs have specific statistical properties. The first few characters often have more entropy or variability, meaning they are less likely to have patterns. The last characters may not maintain this randomness, especially if the encoding method has a tendency to produce less varied endings.
Collision Resistance: When using hashes, the goal is to minimize the risk of collisions (different inputs producing the same output). By using the first few characters, you leverage the full distribution of the hash. The last characters may not distribute in the same way, potentially increasing the likelihood of collisions.
Encoding Characteristics: Base32 encoding has a specific structure and padding that might influence the last characters more than the first. If the data being hashed is similar, the last characters may be more similar across different hashes.
Use Cases: In many applications (like generating unique identifiers), the beginning of the hash is often the most informative and varied. Relying on the end might reduce the uniqueness of generated identifiers, especially if a prefix has a specific context or meaning.
Software as a public good
Open source software underpins all sectors of the economy, public services and even international organizations like the United Nations. How can all its beneficiaries work together to make the open source ecosystem more sustainable?
The post Software as a public good appeared first on The GitHub Blog. ā Read more
An alternate idea for supporting (properly) Twt Edits is to denoate as such and extend the meaning of a Twt Subject (which would need to be called something better?); For example, letās say I produced the following Twt:
2024-09-18T23:08:00+10:00 Hllo World
And my feedās URI is https://example.com/twtxt.txt. The hash for this Twt is therefore 229d24612a2:
$ echo -n "https://example.com/twtxt.txt\n2024-09-18T23:08:00+10:00\nHllo World" | sha1sum | head -c 11
229d24612a2
You wish to correct your mistake, so you make an amendment to that Twt like so:
2024-09-18T23:10:43+10:00 (edit:#229d24612a2) Hello World
Which would then have a new Twt hash value of 026d77e03fa:
$ echo -n "https://example.com/twtxt.txt\n2024-09-18T23:10:43+10:00\nHello World" | sha1sum | head -c 11
026d77e03fa
Clients would then take this edit:#229d24612a2 to mean, this Twt is an edit of 229d24612a2 and should be replaced in the clientās cache, or indicated as such to the user that this is the intended content.
Taking the last n characters of a base32 encoded hash instead of the first n can be problematic for several reasons:
Hash Structure: Hashes are typically designed so that their outputs have specific statistical properties. The first few characters often have more entropy or variability, meaning they are less likely to have patterns. The last characters may not maintain this randomness, especially if the encoding method has a tendency to produce less varied endings.
Collision Resistance: When using hashes, the goal is to minimize the risk of collisions (different inputs producing the same output). By using the first few characters, you leverage the full distribution of the hash. The last characters may not distribute in the same way, potentially increasing the likelihood of collisions.
Encoding Characteristics: Base32 encoding has a specific structure and padding that might influence the last characters more than the first. If the data being hashed is similar, the last characters may be more similar across different hashes.
Use Cases: In many applications (like generating unique identifiers), the beginning of the hash is often the most informative and varied. Relying on the end might reduce the uniqueness of generated identifiers, especially if a prefix has a specific context or meaning.
In summary, using the first n characters generally preserves the intended randomness and collision resistance of the hash, making it a safer choice in most cases.
@quark@ferengi.one Do you mean something like this?
$ ./yarnc debug ~/Public/twtxt.txt | tail -n 1
kp4zitq 2024-09-08T02:08:45Z (#wsdbfna) @<aelaraji https://aelaraji.com/twtxt.txt> My work has this thing called "compressed work", where you can **buy** extra time off (_as much as 4 additional weeks_) per year. It comes out of your pay though, so it's not exactly a 4-day work week but it could be useful, just haven't tired it yet as I'm not entirely sure how it'll affect my net pay
@quark@ferengi.one It looks like the part about traditional topics has been removed from that page. Here is an old version that mentions it: https://web.archive.org/web/20221211165458/https://dev.twtxt.net/doc/twtsubjectextension.html . Still, I donāt see any description of what is actually allowed between the parentheses. May be worth noting that twtxt.net is displaying the twts with the subject stripped, so some piece of code is recognizing it as a subject (or, at least, something to be removed).
MIT Uses AI Chatbots to Brainwash You
Researchers at MIT & Cornell experiment with using A.I. chatbots to stop people from believing in āConspiracy Theoriesā like āelection fraudā. ā Read more
@sorenpeter@darch.dk I like this idea. Just for fun, Iām using a variant in this twt. (Also because Iām curious how it non-hash subjects appear in jenny and yarn.)
URLs can contain commas so I suggest a different character to separate the url from the date. Is this twt Iāve used space (also after āreplytoā, for symmetry).
I think this solves:
- Changing feed identities: although @mckinley@twtxt.net points out URLs can change, I think this syntax should be okay as long as the feed at that URL can be fetched, and as long as the current canonical URL for the feed lists this one as an alternate.
- editing, if you donāt care about message integrity
- finding the root of a thread, if youāre not following the author
An optional hash could be added if message integrity is desired. (E.g. if you donāt trust the feed author not to make a misleading edit.) Other recent suggestions about how to deal with edits and hashes might be applicable then.
People publishing multiple twts per second should include sub-second precision in their timestamps. As you suggested, the timestamp could just be copied verbatim.
@prologic@twtxt.net I have some ideas:
- Add smartypants rendering, just like Yarn has.
- Add the ability to create individual twtxts, each named after their hash.
- Fix the formatting of the help. :-P
@movq@www.uninformativ.de Non-ASCII characters were broken. Like U+2028, degrees (°), etc.
Turns out I used a silly library to detect the encoding and transform to UTF-8 if needed. When there is no Content-Type header, like for local files, it looks at the first 1024 bytes. Since it only saw ASCII in that region, the damn thing assumed the data to be in Windows-1252 (which for web pages kinda makes sense):
// TODO: change default depending on user's locale?
return charmap.Windows1252, "windows-1252", false
https://cs.opensource.google/go/x/net/+/master:html/charset/charset.go;l=102
This default is hardcoded and cannot be changed.
Trying to be smart and adding automatic support for other encodings turned out to be a bad move on my end. At least I can reduce my dependency list again. :-)
I now just reject everything that explicitly specifies something different than text/plain and an optional charset other than utf-8 (ignoring casing). Otherwise I assume itās in UTF-8 (just like the twtxt file format specification mandates) and hope for the best.
(#hash;#originalHash) would also work.
Maybe Iām being a bit too purist/minimalistic here. As I said before (in one of the 1372739 posts on this topic ā or maybe I didnāt even send that twt, I donāt remember š ), I never really liked hashes to begin with. They arenāt super hard to implement but they are kind of against the beauty of the original twtxt ā because you need special client support for them. Itās not something that you could write manually in your
twtxt.txtfile. With @sorenpeter@darch.dkās proposal, though, that would be possible.
Tangentially related, I was a bit disappointed to learn that the twt subject extension is now never used except with hashes. Manually-written subjects sounded so beautifully ad-hoc and organic as a way to disambiguate replies. Maybe Iāll try it some time just for fun.
() @falsifian@www.falsifian.org You mean the idea of being able to inline
# url =changes in your feed?
Yes, that one. But @lyse@lyse.isobeef.org pointed out suffers a compatibility issue, since currently the first listed url is used for hashing, not the last. Unless your feed is in reverse chronological order. Heh, I guess another metadata field could indicate which version to use.
Or maybe url changes could somehow be combined with the archive feeds extension? Could the url metadata field be local to each archive file, so that to switch to a new url all you need to do is archive everything youāve got and start a new file at the new url?
I donāt think itās that likely my feed url will change.
@prologic@twtxt.net Yeah, that thing with (#hash;#originalHash) would also work.
Maybe Iām being a bit too purist/minimalistic here. As I said before (in one of the 1372739 posts on this topic ā or maybe I didnāt even send that twt, I donāt remember š
), I never really liked hashes to begin with. They arenāt super hard to implement but they are kind of against the beauty of the original twtxt ā because you need special client support for them. Itās not something that you could write manually in your twtxt.txt file. With @sorenpeter@darch.dkās proposal, though, that would be possible.
I donāt know ⦠maybe itās just me. š„“
Iām also being a bit selfish, to be honest: Implementing (#hash;#originalHash) in jenny for editing your own feed would not be a no-brainer. (Editing is already kind of unsupported, actually.) It wouldnāt be a problem to implement it for fetching other peopleās feeds, though.
@bender@twtxt.net Itās just a simple twtxt2html and scp ⦠it goes like:
twtxt2html $HOME/path/to/local_twtxt_dir/twtxt.txt > $HOME/path/to/local_twtxt_dir/log.html && \
scp $HOME/path/to/local_twtxt_dir/log.html user@remotehost:/path/to/static_files_dir/
Iāve been lazy to add it to my publish_command script, now I can just copy/pasta from the twt š
@movq@www.uninformativ.de I figured it will be something like this, yet, you were able to reply just fine, and I wasnāt. Looking at your twtxt.txt I see this line:
2024-09-16T17:37:14+00:00 (#o6dsrga) @<prologic https://twtxt.net/user/prologic/twtxt.txt>
@<quark https://ferengi.one/twtxt.txt> This is what I get. š¤
Which is using the right hash. Mine, on the other hand, when I replied to the original, old style message (Message-Id: <o6dsrga>), looks like this:
2024-09-16T16:42:27+00:00 (#o) @<prologic https://twtxt.net/user/prologic/twtxt.txt> this was your first twtxt. Cool! :-P
What did you do to make yours work? I simply went to the oldest @prologic@twtxt.netās entry on my Maildir, and replied to it (jenny set the reply-to hash to #o, even though the Message-Id is o6dsrga). Since jenny canāt fetch archived twtxts, how could I go to re-fetch everything? And, most importantly, would re-fetching fix the Message-Id:?
@movq@www.uninformativ.de Iām glad you like it. A mention (@<movq https://www.uninformativ.de/twtxt.txt>) is also long, but we live with it anyway. In a way a replyto: is just a mention of a twt instead of a feed/person. Maybe we chould even model the syntax for replies on mentions: (#<2024-09-17T08:39:18Z https://www.eksempel.dk/twtxt.txt>) ?!
@mckinley@twtxt.net Yes, changing domains is be a problem if you tie your identity to an https url. But I also worry about being stuck with a key I canāt rotate. Whatever gets used, it would be nice to be able to rotate identities. I like @lyse@lyse.isobeef.orgās idea for that.
(replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)
I think I like this a lot. š¤
The problem with using hashes always was that theyāre āone-directionalā: You can construct a hash from URL + timestamp + twt, but you cannot do the inverse. When I see ā, I have no idea what that could possibly refer to.
But of course something like (replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z) has all the information you need. This could simplify twt/feed discovery quite a bit, couldnāt it? š¤ That thing that I just implemented ā jenny asking some Yarn pod for some twt hash ā would not be necessary anymore. Clients could easily and automatically fetch complete threads instead of requiring the user to follow all relevant feeds.
Only using the timestamp to identify a twt also solves the edit problem.
It even is better for non-Yarn clients, because you now donāt have to read, understand, and implement a ātwt hash specificationā before you can reply to someone.
The only problem, really, is that (replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z) is so long. Clients would have to try harder to hide this. š
iOS 18 Release Is Today ā Check That Your iPhone Supports It
Appleās latest iPhone operating system, iOS 18, brings a host of new features and improvements to iPhones new and old. Itās Appleās biggest software update of the year, and the company is expected to release it sometime on Monday, September 16, likely at around 10:00 a.m. Pacific Time/1:00 p.m. Eastern Time, based on past releases. Keep reading to learn if Appleās upcoming mobile operating system will run on your particular iPhone model ⦠ā Read more
--fetch-context thingy: It can now ask Yarn pods for twt hashes.
@movq@www.uninformativ.de I can have more than one Yarn, correct? Like:
"yarn_pods_for_discovery": ["https://twtxt.net", "https://txt.sour.is"],
More:
Subject: The [tag URI scheme](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tag_URI_scheme) looks interesting. I like that it human read- and writable. And since we already got the timestamp in the twtxt.txt it would be
somewhat trivial to parse. But there are still the issue with what the name/id should be... Maybe it doesn't have to bee that stick? Instead of using `tag:` as the prefix/protocol, it would more it clear
what we are talking about by using `in-reply-to:` (https://indieweb.org/in-reply-to) or `replyto:` similar to `mailto:` 1. `(reply:sorenpeter@darch.dk,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)' 2.
`(in-reply-to:darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)' 2. `(replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)' I know it's longer that 7-11 characters, but it's self-explaining when looking at the
twtxt.txt in the raw, and the cases above can all be caught with this regex: `\([\w-]*reply[\w-]*\:` Is this something that would work?
Subject: The [tag URI scheme](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tag_URI_scheme) looks interesting. I like that it human read- and writable. And since we already got the timestamp in the twtxt.txt it would be
somewhat trivial to parse. But there are still the issue with what the name/id should be... Maybe it doesn't have to bee that stick? Instead of using `tag:` as the prefix/protocol, it would more it clear
what we are talking about by using `in-reply-to:` (https://indieweb.org/in-reply-to) or `replyto:` similar to `mailto:` 1. `(reply:sorenpeter@darch.dk,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)` 2.
`(in-reply-to:darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)` 3. `(replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)` I know it's longer that 7-11 characters, but it's self-explaining when looking at the
twtxt.txt in the raw, and the cases above can all be caught with this regex: `\([\w-]*reply[\w-]*\:` Is this something that would work?
Notice the difference? Soren edited, and broke everything.
Something odd just happened to my twtxt timeline⦠A bunch of twts dissapered, others were marked to be deleted in mutt. so I nuked my whole twtxt Maildir and deleted my ~/.cache/jenny in order to start with a fresh Pull. I pulled feed as usual. Now like HALF the twts arenāt there š even my my last replay. WTF IS GOING ON? š¤£š¤£š¤£
Alright, I saw enough broken threads lately to be motivated enough to extend the --fetch-context thingy: It can now ask Yarn pods for twt hashes.
https://www.uninformativ.de/git/jenny/commit/eefd3fa09083e2206ed0d71887d2ef2884684a71.html
This is only done as a last resort if thereās no other way to find the missing twt. Like, when thereās a twt that begins with just a hash and no user mention, thereās no way for jenny to know on which feed that twt can be found, so itāll ask some Yarn pod in that case.
@mckinley@twtxt.net Thanks for the feedback.
- Yeah I agrees that nick sound not be part of syntax. Any valid URL to a twtxt.txt-file should be enough and is more clear, so it is not confused with a email (one of the the issues with webfinger and fedivese handles)
- I think any valid URL would work, since we are not bound to look for exact matches. Accepting both http and https as well as a gemni and gophe could all work as long as the path to the twtxt.txt is the same.
- My idea is that you quote the timestamp as it is in the original twtxt.txt that you are referring to, so you can do it by simply copy/pasting. Also what are the change that the same human will make two different posts within the same second?!
Regarding the whole cryptographic keys for identity, to me it seems like an unnecessary layer of complexity. If you move to a new house or city you tell people that you moved - you can do the same in a twtxt.txt. Just post something like āI move to this new URL, please follow me there!ā I did that with my feeds at least twice, and you guys still seem to read my posts:)
The tag URI scheme looks interesting. I like that it human read- and writable. And since we already got the timestamp in the twtxt.txt it would be somewhat trivial to parse. But there are still the issue with what the name/id should be⦠Maybe it doesnāt have to bee that stick?
Instead of using tag: as the prefix/protocol, it would more it clear what we are talking about by using in-reply-to: (https://indieweb.org/in-reply-to) or replyto: similar to mailto:
(reply:sorenpeter@darch.dk,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)
(in-reply-to:darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)
(replyto:http://darch.dk/twtxt.txt,2024-09-15T12:06:27Z)
I know itās longer that 7-11 characters, but itās self-explaining when looking at the twtxt.txt in the raw, and the cases above can all be caught with this regex: \([\w-]*reply[\w-]*\:
Is this something that would work?
Thank you @aelaraji@aelaraji.com, Iām glad you like it. I use PHP because itās everywhere on cheap hosting and no need for the user to log into a terminal to setup it up. Timeline is not mean to be use locally. For that I think something like twtxt2html is a better fit. (and happy to see you using simple.css on you new log page;)
Milk-V DuoModule Eval Board with RISC-V Core, 8051 Core, and Linux Support
The Milk-V DuoModule 01 Evaluation Board offers a versatile platform for evaluating the Duo Module 01, featuring Wi-Fi 6, Bluetooth 5.4, and eMMC storage. It enables developers and makers to prototype solutions using the SG2000 SoC, with open-source documentation to streamline development. Like the Milk-V Duo S and Oz64, this board features the SG2000 SoC, [ā¦] ā Read more
M4 Macs, New iPad Mini, and iPad 11 Expected at Upcoming Apple Event
Apple will likely hold another event in October this year to announce new Macs and iPads. If so, it would be the fourth time in the last five years that Apple has held an event in October. Last year, Apple held a virtual event on Monday, October 30 to announce new MacBook Pro and iMac models with the M3 series of chips.
. Today weāre back with a new release of the self-hosted
Snikket server software.
This software is whatās at the core of the Snikket project - a self-hostable
āpersonal messaging server in a boxā. If you wish for something like
Messenger, WhatsApp or Signal, but not using their servers, Snikket is for
you. Once deployed, you can create invitation links for family, f ⦠ā Read more
Extraterrestrial life on Enceladus? š Sounds like sci-fi, but itās science! ā Read more
So this is a great thread. I have been thinking about this too.. and what if we are coming at it from the wrong direction? Identity being tied to a given URL has always been a pain point. If i get a new URL its almost as if i have a new identity because not only am I serving at a new location but all my previous communications are broken because the hashes are all wrong.
What if instead we used this idea of signatures to thread the URLs together into one identity? We keep the URL to Hash in place. Changing that now is basically a no go. But we can create a signature chain that can link identities together. So if i move to a new URL i update the chain hosted by my primary identity to include the new URL. If i have an archived feed that the old URL is now dead, we can point to where it is now hosted and use the current convention of hashing based on the first url:
The signature chain can also be used to rotate to new keys over time. Just sign in a new key or revoke an old one. The prior signatures remain valid within the scope of time the signatures were made and the keys were active.
The signature file can be hosted anywhere as long as it can be fetched by a reasonable protocol. So say we could use a webfinger that directs to the signature file? you have an identity like frank@beans.co that will discover a feed at some URL and a signature chain at another URL. Maybe even include the most recent signing key?
From there the client can auto discover old feeds to link them together into one complete timeline. And the signatures can validate that its all correct.
I like the idea of maybe putting the chain in the feed preamble and keeping the single self contained file.. but wonder if that would cause lots of clutter? The signature chain would be something like a log with what is changing (new key, revoke, add url) and a signature of the change + the previous signature.
# chain: ADDKEY kex14zwrx68cfkg28kjdstvcw4pslazwtgyeueqlg6z7y3f85h29crjsgfmu0w
# sig: BEGIN SALTPACK SIGNED MESSAGE. ...
# chain: ADDURL https://txt.sour.is/user/xuu
# sig: BEGIN SALTPACK SIGNED MESSAGE. ...
# chain: REVKEY kex14zwrx68cfkg28kjdstvcw4pslazwtgyeueqlg6z7y3f85h29crjsgfmu0w
# sig: ...
So this is a great thread. I have been thinking about this too.. and what if we are coming at it from the wrong direction? Identity being tied to a given URL has always been a pain point. If i get a new URL its almost as if i have a new identity because not only am I serving at a new location but all my previous communications are broken because the hashes are all wrong.
What if instead we used this idea of signatures to thread the URLs together into one identity? We keep the URL to Hash in place. Changing that now is basically a no go. But we can create a signature chain that can link identities together. So if i move to a new URL i update the chain hosted by my primary identity to include the new URL. If i have an archived feed that the old URL is now dead, we can point to where it is now hosted and use the current convention of hashing based on the first url:
The signature chain can also be used to rotate to new keys over time. Just sign in a new key or revoke an old one. The prior signatures remain valid within the scope of time the signatures were made and the keys were active.
The signature file can be hosted anywhere as long as it can be fetched by a reasonable protocol. So say we could use a webfinger that directs to the signature file? you have an identity like frank@beans.co that will discover a feed at some URL and a signature chain at another URL. Maybe even include the most recent signing key?
From there the client can auto discover old feeds to link them together into one complete timeline. And the signatures can validate that its all correct.
I like the idea of maybe putting the chain in the feed preamble and keeping the single self contained file.. but wonder if that would cause lots of clutter? The signature chain would be something like a log with what is changing (new key, revoke, add url) and a signature of the change + the previous signature.
# chain: ADDKEY kex14zwrx68cfkg28kjdstvcw4pslazwtgyeueqlg6z7y3f85h29crjsgfmu0w
# sig: BEGIN SALTPACK SIGNED MESSAGE. ...
# chain: ADDURL https://txt.sour.is/user/xuu
# sig: BEGIN SALTPACK SIGNED MESSAGE. ...
# chain: REVKEY kex14zwrx68cfkg28kjdstvcw4pslazwtgyeueqlg6z7y3f85h29crjsgfmu0w
# sig: ...
HaloMax Product Line for Long-Range, Low-Power Wireless Solutions
Teledaticsā HaloMax, recently featured on CrowdSupply, is a long-range wireless module designed for applications like smart agriculture, industrial control, and HAM radio. Operating in the sub-1 GHz band, it delivers reliable, power-efficient communication over extended distances with FCC-allowed maximum output power. The HaloMax product lineup offers a range of modules and accessories tailored for long-range [ā¦] ā Read more
The Self-Destruction of Open Source Software
Is it on purpose? It sure seems like itās on purpose. ā Read more
url field in the feed to define the URL for hashing. It should have been the last encountered one. Then, assuming append-style feeds, you could override the old URL with a new one from a certain point on:
how little data is needed for generating the hashes? Instead of the full URL, can we makedo with just the domain (example.net) so we avoid the conflicts with gemini://, https:// and only http:// (like in my own twtxt.txt) or construct something like like a webfinger id nick@domain (also used by mastodon etc.) from the domain and nick if there, else use domain as nick as well
@lyse@lyse.isobeef.org This looks like a nice way to do it.
Another thought: if clients canāt agree on the url (for example, if we switch to this new way, but some old clients still do it the old way), that could be mitigated by computing many hashes for each twt: one for every url in the feed. So, if a feed has three URLs, every twt is associated with three hashes when it comes time to put threads together.
A client stills need to choose one url to use for the hash when composing a reply, but this might add some breathing room if thereās a period when clients are doing different things.
(From what I understand of jenny, this would be difficult to implement there since each pseudo-email can only have one msgid to match to the in-reply-to headers. I donāt know about other clients.)
Gurman: No Apple Watch Ultra 3 Tomorrow, Ultra 2 in Black Likely
Bloombergās Mark Gurman today said that he does not expect Apple to announce an Apple Watch Ultra 3 at its event tomorrow. Instead, he believes that Apple will introduce a black color option for the Apple Watch Ultra 2.
Apple supply chain analyst Ming-Chi Kuo was first to ind ⦠ā Read more
@movq@www.uninformativ.de Another idea: just hash the feed url and time, without the message content. And donāt twt more than once per second.
Maybe you could even just use the time, and rely on @-mentions to disambiguate. Not sure how that would work out.
Though I kind of like the idea of twts being immutable. At least, itās clear which version of a twt youāre replying to (assuming nobody is engineering hash collisions).
@prologic@twtxt.net Some criticisms and a possible alternative direction:
Key rotation. Iām not a security person, but my understanding is that itās good to be able to give keys an expiry date and replace them with new ones periodically.
It makes maintaining a feed more complicated. Now instead of just needing to put a file on a web server (and scan the logs for user agents) I also need to do this. What brought me to twtxt was its radical simplicity.
Instead, maybe we should think about a way to allow old urls to be rotated out? Like, my metadata could somehow say that X used to be my primary URL, but going forward from date D onward my primary url is Y. (Or, if you really want to use public key cryptography, maybe something similar could be used for key rotation there.)
Itās nice that your scheme would add a way to verify the twts you download, but https is supposed to do that anyway. If you donāt trust https to do that (maybe you donāt like relying on root CAs?) then maybe your preferred solution should be reflected by your primary feed url. E.g. if you prefer the security offered by IPFS, then maybe an IPNS url would do the trick. The fact that feed locations are URLs gives some flexibility. (But then rotation is still an issue, if I understand ipns right.)
On the Subject of Feed Identities; I propose the following:
- Generate a Private/Public ED25519 key pair
- Use this key pair to sign your Twtxt feed
- Use it as your feedās identity in place of
# url =as# key = ...
For example:
$ ssh-keygen -f prologic@twtxt.net
$ ssh-keygen -Y sign -n prologic@twtxt.net -f prologic@twtxt.net twtxt.txt
And your feed would looke like:
# nick = prologic
# key = SHA256:23OiSfuPC4zT0lVh1Y+XKh+KjP59brhZfxFHIYZkbZs
# sig = twtxt.txt.sig
# prev = j6bmlgq twtxt.txt/1
# avatar = https://twtxt.net/user/prologic/avatar#gdoicerjkh3nynyxnxawwwkearr4qllkoevtwb3req4hojx5z43q
# description = "Problems are Solved by Method" š¦šŗšØāš»šØāš¦Æš¹ā šāÆ šØāš©āš§āš§š„ -- James Mills (operator of twtxt.net / creator of Yarn.social š§¶)
2024-06-14T18:22:17Z (#nef6byq) @<bender https://twtxt.net/user/bender/twtxt.txt> Hehe thanks! š
Still gotta sort out some other bugs, but that's tomorrows job š¤
...
Twt Hash extension would change of course to use a feedās ED25519 public key fingerprint.
macOS Sequoia Release Likely to Be the Earliest in Years
macOS Sequoia will be one of the earliest new macOS launches in over a decade, likely releasing within as little as just a week.
Internal Apple documentation obtained by MacRumors suggests that macOS 15.0 Sequoia will be officially released to the public by mid-September. The release dates of major macOS updates in ⦠ā Read more
@bender@twtxt.net Yes, they do 𤣠Implicitly, or threading would never work at all š Nor lookups 𤣠They are used as keys. Think of them like a primary key in a database or index. I totally get where youāre coming from, but there are trade-offs with using Message/Thread Ids as opposed to Content Addressing (like we do) and I believe we would just encounter other problems by doing so.
My money is on extending the Twt Subject extension to support more (optional) advanced āsubjectsā; i.e: indicating you edited a Twt you already published in your feed as @falsifian@www.falsifian.org indicated š
Then we have a secondary (bure much rarer) problem of the āidentityā of a feed in the first place. Using the URL you fetch the feed from as @lyse@lyse.isobeef.org ās client tt seems to do or using the # url = metadata field as every other client does (according to the spec) is problematic when you decide to change where you host your feed. In fact the spec says:
Users are advised to not change the first one of their urls. If they move their feed to a new URL, they should add this new URL as a new url field.
See Choosing the Feed URL ā This is one of our longest debates and challenges, and I think (_I suspect along with @xuu@txt.sour.is _) that the right way to solve this is to use public/private key(s) where you actually have a public key fingerprint as your feedās unique identity that never changes.
@movq@www.uninformativ.de @prologic@twtxt.net Another option would be: when you edit a twt, prefix the new one with (#[old hash]) and some indication that itās an edited version of the original tweet with that hash. E.g. if the hash used to be abcd123, the new version should start ā(#abcd123) (redit)ā.
What I like about this is that clients that donāt know this convention will still stick it in the same thread. And I feel itās in the spirit of the old pre-hash (subject) convention, though thatās before my time.
I guess it may not work when the edited twt itself is a reply, and there are replies to it. Maybe that could be solved by letting twts have more than one (subject) prefix.
But the great thing about the current system is that nobody can spoof message IDs.
I donāt think twtxt hashes are long enough to prevent spoofing.
All this hash breakage made me wonder if we should try to introduce āmessage IDsā after all. š
But the great thing about the current system is that nobody can spoof message IDs. š¤ When you think about it, message IDs in e-mails only work because (almost) everybody plays fair. Nothing stops me from using the same Message-ID header in each and every mail, that would break e-mail threading all the time.
In Yarn, twt hashes are derived from twt content and feed metadata. That is pretty elegant and Iād hate see us lose that property.
If we wanted to allow editing twts, we could do something like this:
2024-09-05T13:37:40+00:00 (~mp6ox4a) Hello world!
Here, mp6ox4a would be a āpartial hashā: To get the actual hash of this twt, youād concatenate the feedās URL and mp6ox4a and get, say, hlnw5ha. (Pretty similar to the current system.) When people reply to this twt, they would have to do this:
2024-09-05T14:57:14+00:00 (~bpt74ka) (<a href="https://txt.sour.is/search?q=%23hlnw5ha">#hlnw5ha</a>) Yes, hello!
That second twt has a partial hash of bpt74ka and is a reply to the full hash hlnw5ha. The author of the āHello world!ā twt could then edit their twt and change it to 2024-09-05T13:37:40+00:00 (~mp6ox4a) Hello friends! or whatever. Threading wouldnāt break.
Would this be worth it? Itās certainly not backwards-compatible. š
@bender@twtxt.net So far Iāve been following feeds fairly liberally. Iāll check to see if we have anything in common and lean toward following, just because this is new to me and it feels like a small community. But Iām still figuring out what I want. Later Iāll probably either trim my follower list or come up with some way to prioritize the feeds Iām more interested in.
@lyse@lyse.isobeef.org 31°C here, feels like 33°C, with a lovely 75% of humidity. It has been raining, on and off (to make matter ābetterā) the whole day until now. No horses here, but if you go outside you will smell the same smell of farm animals (like goats, or pigs). Thatās because two or three kilometres from here there are private farms, and when the wind blows in such way, well, we are reminded of their existence.
I havenāt left the house, so it feels well under air conditioning. In two more hours I will call it quits from the work day, and will have to dash to the grocery to get supplies for tonightās meal (arroz con gandules). I will let you know how it truly feels out there then. :-D
For those swollen fingers, nothing better than a mildly cold shower! Oh, and paws off the keyboard! :-P
When we passed a few horses in the forest, there was really strong soup odor in the air. It didnāt smell like horse at all, but soup. Maybe theyāve been soup horses, chickens were out of stock.
29°C, zero wind, extremely humid, luckily the sun was behind the clouds. Iām soaking wet, sweat ran down in streams and dripped in my eyes, it burned a bit. The sky is getting a little dark, I hope the thunderstorm and rain are really arriving here later. Rain had always been finally cancelled the couple last days.
Iām gotta go cool off my fingers now, theyāre swollen from the heat.
@dbucklin@www.davebucklin.com very nice, thank you for sharing! I like that kind of retailers too, so those are on my list now. š
Erlang Solutions: Meet the team: Joanna Wrona
In this edition of our āMeet the Teamā series, weād like to introduce you to Joanna Wrona, Business Unit Leader for the Kraków office at Erlang Solutions.
She discusses her role at ESL and her passion for empowering her team. She also gives us a glimpse into life in beautiful Kraków and what makes her journey so fulfilling.
About Joanna**What is your ⦠ā Read more
@prologic@twtxt.net I guess I thought they were search engines. Anyway, the registry API looks like a decent one for searching for tweets. Could/should yarn.social pods implement the same API?
@prologic@twtxt.net How does yarn.socialās API fix the problem of centralization? I still need to know whose API to use.
Say I see a twt beginning (#hash) and I want to look up the start of the thread. Is the idea that if that twt is hosted by a a yarn.social pod, it is likely to know the thread start, so I should query that particular pod for the hash? But what if no yarn.social pods are involved?
The community seems small enough that a registry server should be able to keep up, and I can have a couple of others as backups. Or I could crawl the list of feeds followed by whoever emitted the twt that prompted my query.
I have successfully used registry servers a little bit, e.g. to find a feed that mentioned a tag I was interested in. Was even thinking of making my own, if I get bored of my too many other projects :-)
Anker Launches Latest MagGo Charging Accessories With Qi2
Popular accessory company Anker is launching the latest updates to its MagGo lineup today, showing off a series of five products largely based around Qi2 wireless charging technology that supports magnetic connections and up to 15 watts of charging power, just like Appleās MagSafe standard.
⦠ā Read more
iPadOS 18 is Compatible with These iPads
iPadOS 18 for iPad includes some exciting new features for iPad users, from more interface customization options like Dark Mode icons and widgets, color hued icons and widgets, a customizable Control Center, the debut of a Calculator app for iPad, Passwords app, a Photos redesign, improvements to Notes app, new features in Safari like Distraction ⦠Read More ā Read more
Kubernetes turns 10: a ditty dedicated to a decade of container orchestration
Member post originally published on Fairwindsā blog by Stevie Caldwell Itās hard to believe, but Kubernetes, our favorite container orchestration tool,Ā turned tenĀ this year! It feels like just yesterday when it was just an internal project at Google spinning⦠ā Read more
Beats Teases New Powerbeats Pro 2 Coming Next Year
Beats today teased that new Powerbeats Pro 2 are coming next year, but it did not share a specific release date for the wireless headphones.
MLB superstar Shohei Ohtani can be seen wearing the Powerbeats Pro 2 in a clip shared on social media platforms like Instagram and X. They look similar to the existin ⦠ā Read more
The far-right is the only place left for Elon Muskās X-rated ego
Many are wondering how the poster boy for futurism ended up sounding like a conspiracy-theory-spouting uncle. But what if weāre all missing the point? ā Read more
** September summer **
I finished reading Robin Sloanās Moonbound today. It was fun, and light. The blurb likens it to Narnia, and, while a bold claim, I think that was a correct assertion, but more about the intended audience than the bookās subject matter. If a sequel is ever written Iād most certainly give it a look. It seems like a great gift book for a kid between like 8 and 15ā¦or you know, perhaps, anyone who likes fun stories that arenāt scared of bein ⦠ā Read more
Found this in an old copyright notice from 1993:
These images are not for use with the Microsoft Windows environment. Using these patterns in a Windows environment consitutes a copyright violation.
Someone clearly didnāt like Windows.
āWe have a lot of issuesā: Billionaire tech boss lifts lid on staff turnover
Airwallex CEO Jack Zhang says a lack of resources means he canāt compete with the likes of Canva or Atlassian in work perks. ā Read more
@mckinley@twtxt.net agevault uses age, allegedly very secure (aiming to replace pgp/gpg). Comparing it with gocryptfs, from the user perspective, agevault seems simpler, though CLI exclusive. As the repository states, āLike age, it features no config options, allowing for a straightforward secure flowā. It would also run in all major OS platforms out of the box.
But agevault is also very new. Though age has been around for a while now, I donāt see an āauditedā link (neither on agevault, nor age).
Spotify Blames Apple for Loss of iPhone Volume Button Control of Connected Devices
Spotify says users on iPhone will no longer be able to control the volume of connected devices using their physical volume buttons after Apple ā discontinuedā the technology that enables the functionality. The change impacts Spotify Connect, a feature that allows users to control Spotify playback on various devices like speakers, game ⦠ā Read more
Can a sandworm really zoom like that in Dune? š Had to set Colbert straight on the science ā Read more
Erlang Solutions: 5 Ways MongooseIM Provides Scalable and Future-Proof Messaging
CTOs with instant messaging requirements are facing a challenge. Whether they are looking to improve an existing instant messaging system or implement one for the first time, they need a messaging solution that can scale to meet growing demands. It must also integrate with existing systems and remain future-proof against technological changes. It sounds like a lot to ask for, but traditi ⦠ā Read more
Thereās like one game a year thatās played in Ireland⦠Or every other year. I donāt know why⦠advertising to get college football worldwide?
The Snake-Like Robots Searching for Life on Saturnās Moon ā Read more
Kubestronaut in Orbit: Fangel Colón
Get to know Fangel This weekās Kubestronaut in Orbit, Fangel Emilio Colón Navarro, lives in the Dominican Republic and is an SRE at Banco BHD. Heās been working with CNCF technologies since 2020. If youād like to be⦠ā Read more
@abucci@anthony.buc.ci You can also use -R=false on the command line or leave it out entirely. When explicitly stating -R=false, there has to be an equal sign. With a space (-R false) itās somehow parsed as -R which is equivalent to -R=true. O_o Very weird. Iād really like to see an error instead.
I still have to figure out the precedence of the settings.yaml or command line arguments. Iām probably holding it wrong, but it seems to give me different resultsā¦
vim cursor at the end of the first line on replies, and forks. I have tried adding to this to jenny's configuration:
@movq@www.uninformativ.de hmm, I guess I could do that too. I have startinsert set on my .vimrc, so I will either have to take it out, or exit insert, $, then insert again. I think the way you do it would be the way to go.
I tried setting VISUAL to be something like vim -c 'star!', which does the same thing, but no dice. :-/
POWER EFFINā OUTAGE!!! Electricity came back after ~10 min like⦠no beggie BUT, Internet stayed out for like 2 more hrs š
Building a translation agent on LlamaEdge
Member post originally published on Second Stateās blog Prof. Andrew NgāsĀ agentic translationĀ is a great demonstration on how to coordinate multiple LLM āagentsā to work on a single task. It allows multiple smaller LLMs (like Llama-3 or Gemma-2) to⦠ā Read more
16GB of RAM Could Be the New Minimum in Appleās Upcoming M4 Macs
All of Appleās upcoming new Macs this year are likely to have at least 16GB of RAM pre-installed as standard, breaking a years-long tradition of Apple offering just 8GB of RAM in most of its base Macs and forcing customers to pay out an extra $200+ for additional memory.
The adequacy of 8GB of RAM in Macs has been a [contentious issue](https:/ ⦠ā Read more
There is a bug in yarnd thatās been around for awhile and is still present in the current version Iām running that lets a person hit a constructed URL like
YOUR_POD/external?nick=lovetocode999&uri=https://socialmphl.com/story19510368/doujin
and see a legitimate-looking page on YOUR_POD, with an HTTP code 200 (success). From that fake page you can even follow an external feed. Try it yourself, replacing āYOUR_PODā with the URL of any yarnd pod you know. Try following the feed.
I think URLs like this should return errors. They should not render HTML, nor produce legitimate-looking pages. This mechanism is ripe for DDoS attacks. My pod gets roughly 70,000 hits per day to URLs like this. Many are porn or other types of content I do not want. At this point, if itās not fixed soon I am going to have to shut down my pod. @prologic@twtxt.net please have a look.
@falsifian@www.falsifian.org @bender@twtxt.net I pushed an alternative implementation to the fetch-context branch. This integrates the whole thing into mutt/jenny.
You will want to configure a new mutt hotkey, similar to the āreplyā hotkey:
macro index,pager <esc>C "\
<enter-command> set my_pipe_decode=\$pipe_decode nopipe_decode<Enter>\
<pipe-message> jenny -c<Enter>\
<enter-command> set pipe_decode=\$my_pipe_decode; unset my_pipe_decode<Enter>" \
"Try to fetch context of current twt, like a missing root twt"
This pipes the mail to jenny -c. jenny will try to find the thread hash and the URL and then fetch it. (If thereās no URL or if the specific twt cannot be found in that particular feed, it could query a Yarn pod. That is not yet implemented, though.)
The whole thing looks like this:
https://movq.de/v/0d0e76a180/jenny.mp4
In other words, when thereās a missing root twt, you press a hotkey to fetch it, done.
I think I like this version better. š¤
(This needs a lot of testing. š)
How to Run Llama LLM on Mac, Locally
Llama is a powerful large language model (LLM) developed by Meta (yes, the same Meta that is Facebook), that is able to process and generate human-like text. Itās quite similar to ChatGPT, but what is unique about Llama is that you can run it locally, directly on your computer. With a little effort, youāll be ⦠Read More ā Read more
@movq@www.uninformativ.de you said you liked seeing the hash (which is a fair choice!). All I am asking is for a reconsideration as a user configurable feature. ;-) It looks redundant, in my opinion.
@bender@twtxt.net Iām not a yarnd user, but automatically unfollowing on 404 doesnāt seem right. Besides @lyse@lyse.isobeef.orgās example, I could imagine just accidentally renaming my own twtxt file, or forgetting to push it when I point my DNS to a new web server. Iād rather not lose all my yarnd followers in a situation like that (and hopefully they feel the same).
159-196-9-199.9fc409.mel.nbn.aussiebb.net
@bender@twtxt.net 404 could be indeed a temporary error if the file resides on a mounted remote filesystem and then the mount point fails for some reason. With a symlink from the web root to the file on the mount, the web server probably will not recognize the mount point failure as such. Thus, it might not reply with a 503 Service Unavailable (or something like that), but 404 Not Found instead. (I could be wrong on that, though.)
The right⢠way is to signal 410 Gone if the feed does not exist anymore and will not come back to life again. But thatās hard to come by in the wild. Somebody has to manually configure that in almost all situations.
But yes, as @falsifian@www.falsifian.org points out, exponential backoff looks like a good strategy. Probably even report a failure to users somehow, so they can check and potentially unsubscribe.
159-196-9-199.9fc409.mel.nbn.aussiebb.net
@prologic@twtxt.net @bender@twtxt.net Exponential backoff? Seems like the right thing to do when a server isnāt accepting your connections at all, and might also be a reasonable compromise if you consider 404 to be a temporary failure.